Philosophy of Social Science

Ryan Muldoon

[image of Ryan Muldoon]
Contact Information
Email address: 
Dissertation Title: 
Diversity and the Social Contract
Research Interests: 

My dissertation project, "Diversity and the Social Contract", is an attempt to lay the foundations for a novel formulation of social contract theory in which diversity is a central concern. To do this, I offer a new moral stance that allows for substantive, fundamental moral disagreement, and then use this moral stance to develop a bargaining model in which agents can cooperate with only minimal conditions on their agreement. I demonstrate that, up to certain limits, a more diverse population is one that is more able to provide public goods. This framework is then used to argue that we ought to replace a notion of toleration with a more aggressive embrace of diversity. I see this project as an attempt to bring Mill's conception of experiments in living into the fold of contract theory.

Previous Degrees: 

M.A. in Philosophy, University of Pennsylvania

B.S. in Philosophy (with honors), University of Wisconsin - Madison

B.S. in Mathematics, University of Wisconsin - Madison

Publications: 

"Robust Simulations" Philosophy of Science 74 (December 2007)

"Epistemic Landscapes and the Division of Cognitive Labor" (With Michael Weisberg) Philosophy of Science (Forthcoming)

"Robustness and Idealization in Models of Cognitive Labor" (With Michael Weisberg) (Under Review)

Presentations: 

"The View from Everywhere" The Epistemology of Liberal Democracy – Free Speech, Disagreement and Common Belief University of Copenhagen, Denmark, November 2008

"Epistemic Diversity and Epistemic Landscapes" Biennial Meeting of the Philosophy of Science Association, Pittsburgh, November 2008

"Toward a Mechanism for Realizing Mill’s Experiments in Living" Tenth Conference of the International Society for Utilitarian Studies Kadish Center for Morality, Law and Public Affairs, UC – Berkeley, September 2008

"Agreeing to Disagree: How Conflicting Norms Can be Mutually Reinforcing" Fundacion Urrutia Elejalde XI Summer School on Economics and Philosophy: Social Norms San Sebastian, Spain, July 2008

"Spatial Models of Bargaining" Formal Methods in Philosophy Workshop University of Pennsylvania, May 2008

"Diversity and the Public Sphere" Democracy, Constitutionalism and Citizenship Graduate Workshop, University of Pennsylvania, November 2007.

"Correlating Strategies With Neighbors Even When The Goal is Anti-Correlation" 2007 Meeting of the International Society for the History, Philosophy, and Social Studies of Biology, Exeter, England, July 2007

"Diversity and the Social Contract" Santa Fe Institute Graduate Workshop in Computational Social Science Modeling and Complexity, Santa Fe, New Mexico, July 2007

"Social Epistemology and Individual Rationality" Fourth Annual Formal Epistemology Workshop, Carnegie Mellon University, May 2007

"How Computer Simulations are like Telescopes and Microscopes" Philosophy of Science Association 2006 Biennial Meeting, Vancouver, November 2006

Comments on Epsen's "Games with Zero-Knowledge Signaling" Third Annual Formal Epistemology Workshop, UC - Berkeley, May 2006

"The Emergence of Trust: Preventing Conflicts with Covenants" Mind, Brain, and Behavior Graduate Student Conference, Harvard University, May 2006

"The Need for a Plurality of Fairness Norms: An Evolutionary Account" Computing and Philosophy Conference (CAP 2005), Oregon State University, August, 2005

"Fairness Plurality: An Evolutionary Account" Social Network Analysis: Advances and Applications Forum, Oxford University, July, 2005

"Modeling the Emergence of Multiple Fairness Norms" (with Cristina Bicchieri) Social Dynamics Workshop, Santa Fe Institute, April, 2005

"On The Validity of Model-Based Arguments" Graduate Philosophy Conference, University of Pittsburgh and Carnegie Mellon University, April 2005

Awards: 

2007: Summer School Support and Travel Award Santa Fe Institute

2007: Dean's Summer Fellowship in Philosophy Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, University of Pennsylvania

2006: PSA Travel Grant Philosophy of Science Association and the National Science Foundation

2006: Summer School Support and Travel Award Santa Fe Institute

2006: Summer Research Grant
Graduate School of Arts and Sciences, University of Pennsylvania

2005: Russell Ackoff Doctoral Student Fellowship for Research on Human Decision Processes Center for Risk and Decision Processes, The Wharton School

2005: Provost's Travel Grant to attend Symposium on Risk and Uncertainty University of Pennsylvania

2005: Philosophy, Politics, and Economics Summer Research Travel Grant University of Pennsylvania

2004: Philosophy, Politics, and Economics Conference Travel Grant University of Pennsylvania

Advisors: 

Cristina Bicchieri, Adrienne Martin, Samuel Freeman, Michael Weisberg

Cristina Bicchieri

[image ]
Sascha Jane Patterson Harvie Professor of Social Thought and Comparative Ethics
Ph.D. Cambridge University
Laurea (Summa cum Laude) University of Milano
Contact Information
Phone: 
(215) 898-5820
Email address: 
Office Location: 
491 Cohen Hall
Appointments: 

Professor of Philosophy

Professor of Legal Studies, Wharton School

Member of Graduate Group, Psychology

Director, Philosophy, Politics, and Economics Program (http://www.sas.upenn.edu/ppe/index.html)

For more information, my personal page is http://www.sas.upenn.edu/~cb36/index.html

For recently posted papers, go to http://upenn.academia.edu/CristinaBicchieri

Research Interests: 

My intellectual affinities lie at the border between philosophy, game theory and psychology. My primary research focus is on judgment and decision making with special interest in decisions about fairness, trust, and cooperation, and how expectations affect behavior. A second research focus examines the nature and evolution of social norms, especially norms of fairness and cooperation. A third, earlier research focus has been the epistemic foundations of game theory and how changes in information affects rational choices and solutions.

• In my most recent work, I have designed behavioral experiments aimed at testing several hypotheses based on the theory of social norms that I developed in my book, The Grammar of Society: the Nature and Dynamics of Social Norms (Cambridge University Press, 2006). The experimental results show that most subjects have a conditional preference for following pro-social norms. Manipulating their expectations causes major behavioral changes (i.e., from fair to unfair choices, from cooperation to defection, etc.). One of the conclusions we may draw is that there are no such things as stable dispositions or unconditional preferences (to be fair, reciprocate, cooperate, and so on). Another is that policymakers who want to induce pro-social behavior have to work on changing people's expectations about how other people behave in similar situations. These results have major consequences for our understanding of moral behavior and the construction of better normative theories, grounded on what people can in fact do.

• The nature and dynamics of social norms studies how norms may emerge and become stable, why an established norm may suddenly be abandoned, how is it possible that inefficient or unpopular norms survive, and what motivates people to obey norms. In order to answer some of these questions, I have combined evolutionary and game-theoretic tools with models of decision making drawn from cognitive and social psychology. For example, I use my theory of context-dependent preferences to build more realistic evolutionary models of the emergence of pro-social norms of fairness and reciprocity.

• My earlier (but never completely abandoned) research focus was the epistemic foundations of game theory. I recently wrote about belief-revision in games, and what kind of solutions our belief-revision model supports. In my past work I have analyzed the consequences of relaxing the 'common knowledge' assumption in several classes of games. My contributions include axiomatic models of players' theory of the game and the proof that -- in a large class of games -- a player's theory of the game is consistent only if the player's knowledge is limited. An important consequence of assuming bounded knowledge is that it allows for more intuitive solutions to familiar games such as the finitely repeated prisoner's dilemma or the chain-store paradox. I have also been interested in devising mechanical procedures (algorithms) that allow players to compute solutions for games of perfect and imperfect information. Devising such procedures is particularly important for Artificial Intelligence applications, since interacting software agents have to be programmed to play a variety of 'games'.

Selected Publications: 

Social Norms, The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy, 2011

"Norms, Preferences, and Conditional Behavior" , Politics, Philosophy and Economics 9(3), 2010

“Trustworthiness is a Social Norm, but Trusting is not ” (with Erte Xiao and Ryan Muldoon). Politics, Philosophy and Economics 10 (2), 2011

"Words or Deeds? Choosing What to Know about Others" (with Erte Xiao). Synthese (forthcoming)

"Studying the ethical implications of e-trust in the lab" (with Azi Lev-On). Ethics and Information Technology 13 (1), 2011

“The Medium or the Message? Communication Richness and Relevance in Trust games” (with Azi Lev-On and Alex Chavez), Synthese 176 (1): 2010

"When Equality Trumps Reciprocity" (with Erte Xiao). Journal of Economic Psychology 31(3), 2010

"Behaving as Expected: Public Information and Fairness Norms" (with Alex Chavez), Journal of Behavioral Decision Making 23 (2): 161-178, 2010

“An Embarrassment of Riches: Modeling Social Preferences in Ultimatum games”, (with. Jiji Zhang) in U. Maki (ed) Handbook of the Philosophy of Economics, Elsevier 2010

“Group and Dyadic Communication in Trust Games” (with Azi Lev-On and Alex Chavez). Rationality and Society, 22(1), 2010

“Do the right thing: but only if others do so” (with Erte Xiao). Journal of Behavioral Decision Making, 22: 191-208, 2009

“Rationality and Indeterminacy”, in D. Ross and H. Kinkaid (eds.) The Handbook of Philosophy of Economics, The Oxford Reference Library of Philosophy, Oxford University Press 2009: 159-188.

“The Fragility of Fairness: An Experimental Investigation on the Conditional Status of Pro-social Norms”, Nous. Philosophical Issues: Interdisciplinary Core Philosophy, 2008 “Computer-Mediated Communication and Cooperation in Social Dilemmas: An Experimental Analysis” (with Azi Lev-On), Politics, Philosophy and Economics, vol.6:139-168, 2007

"Knowing and Supposing in Games of Perfect Information" (with Horacio Arlo-Costa). Studia Logica, Vol. 86, n.3: 353-373, 2007

“Game Theory: Some Personal Reflections," Game Theory 5 Questions, V. F. Hendricks and P. G. Hansen, eds, Automatic Press, 2007.

Books

The Grammar of Society: the Nature and Dynamics of Social Norms, Cambridge University Press, 2006 For more information see www.cambridge.org/9780521574907

Rationality and Coordination, Cambridge University Press, 1993; Second edition, 1997. Italian translation, Feltrinelli, 1998

The Logic of Strategy, C. Bicchieri, R. Jeffrey and B. Skyrms (eds.), Oxford University Press, 1999

The Dynamics of Norms, C. Bicchieri, R. Jeffrey and B. Skyrms (eds.), Cambridge University Press, 1997

Knowledge, Belief, and Strategic Interaction, C. Bicchieri and M.L. dalla Chiara (eds.), Cambridge University Press 1992

Ragioni per Credere, Ragioni per Fare. Convenzioni e Vincoli nel Metodo Scientifico, Feltrinelli, Milano, 1988

Syndicate content